The big news yesterday was the failed merger talks between Sun Microsystems and IBM. Sun Microsystems (JAVA) lost almost 23% of its value after the news hit the street. JAVA exploded on March 17 after rumors of a potential bid by IBM made Sun’s shares 79% more expensive.
The major sticking point was that Sun Micro believed IBM’s rumored offer of $9.40 to be too low. This news should be a lesson for all would be merger arbitrageurs to never initiate a position in an arb deal before the deal has been announced officially. Without a clear written intent from both companies, there is added uncertainty whether the deal would go through in order for the arbitrageur to close their position at a profit. That’s why arbitrageurs should expect higher risk adjusted returns if they waited for the official announcement of the deal before deciding whether the deal is worth participating in or not.
Another example of a badly timed merger arb play was the talks between Yahoo (YHOO) and Microsoft (MSFT) early in 2008. Back in February 2008, MSFT proposed to acquire YHOO for $31/share, which was a 62% premium to the closing price for the dot com company. After the announcement Yahoo jumped by 48% to 28.38. Check out my analysis of MSFT.
After three months of uncertainties however Microsoft decided that Yahoo (YHOO) valued itself too much and withdrew from negotiations, sending Yahoo shares down 15% for the day. Investors and institutions which bought Yahoo (YHOO) stock around $28.38 expecting to make an easy 9% gain were hugely disappointed.
As always, once the intent of BOTH companies is announced in favor of the deal and all the details have been accepted by both companies, should one consider initiating a merger arbitrage play. Otherwise, you would be speculating, which is not what Ben Graham and Warren Buffett preach as a winning investment philosophy.
This post appeared on Carnival of Personal Finance #200 - Edition of Mini Accomplishments
Relevant Articles:
- Warren Buffett – The Ultimate Dividend Investor
- 40 Value Stocks that Graham Would Buy
- Arbitrage Opportunities – CEG and ROH
- Microsoft (MSFT) Dividend Stock Analysis
Popular Posts
-
Realty Income (O) stock reached an all-time-high of $82.29/share in February 2020, or about five years ago. Today, the stock is selling at $...
-
I review the list of dividend increases every week as part of my monitoring process. Dividend increases provide signaling value to me in my ...
-
As a shareholder, there are two ways to make profits from a stock. The first way is when you sell your stock for a gain, after it has incre...
-
I came upon an interesting story about another dividend investor, this time a famous actor. This is Sean William Scott, who starred in such ...
-
I review the list of dividend increases every week, as part of my monitoring process. This exercise helps me monitor existing positions. I a...
-
I am a big fan of diversification. That doesn't just mean owning a lot of companies however. It means spreading the risk. You need to un...
-
I tend to focus my attention on companies that regularly increase dividends to shareholders . A long history of annual dividend increases is...
-
I review the list of dividend increases every week as part of my monitoring process. Dividend increases provide signaling value to me in my ...
-
I was reviewing my old files and re-visited an interesting paper from Standard & Poor's from a few years ago about the importance of...
-
In terms of a somewhat succint summary, it is good to think in terms of trade-offs in the full picture. The expected returns formula I use r...
